Surrender @ his lotus feet
Friday, April 22, 2005
  Did Lord Rama eat meat?
A very common question from many people - Did Lord Rama eat meat? There was one such question on the jetusa yahoogroups to Swamiji. the question read as follows:

"Jai Srimannarayana, Dear swamiji, there are a few questions which are haunting me from the past few months. I am currently living in Australia where I have negligible help in the matter of Hinduism. I was asked some questions by few of my friends which probably have made my existance very miserable as a Hindu. I was ashamed that I could not explain anything to him about what is Hinduism. One of the major questions which he asked was if Lord Rama can eat beef meat then why don't you eat meat as Rama is known as one of the incarnations of Lord Vishnu. On this I said very blandly that Rama does not eat meat. After hearing what I said, he laughed at me and showed me few phrases from the Ramayana which state that Rama, before going to exile told his mother that he would miss his favourite food which is beef meat. Now my doubt is why would Rama eat beef meat when cow is known as a sacred animal. It forms an illusion in my mind and raises many doubts about our Hindu culture and beliefs, I am saying because I daily recite Vishnu Sahasranama without actually knowing why am I doing that. I have also decided to visit the JET school in Badrinath when I come back to India to know more about our culture and beliefs. Waiting for a reply
Vishnu Bhakta, S.Aravind Bhave Australia"

Swamiji very eloquently replied as follows:

"Priya sriman Vishnu Bhaktaji!

JAI SRIMANNARAYANA!

WE ARE HAPPY FOR YOUR CURIOUSITY IN KNOWING SOMETHING ABOUT OUR CULTURE AND HERITAGE. SRI RAMA DID EAT MEAT. THAT IS MENTIONED IN SRIRAMAYANAM ON SEVERAL OCCASSIONS. THEN WHAT? IF RAMA ATE, SHOULD YOU ALSO HAVE TO EAT IT? RAMA DID MANY A THING. ARE THESE PEOPLE, WHO ARE POSING DIFFERENT QUESTIONS, DOING ALL OF THEM? THEY WANT TO CHOOSE CONVENIENTLY A FEW THINGS, WHERE THEY CAN GRATIFY THEIR SENSES. OR SATISFY THEIR WEAKNESSES.

DURING THOSE TIMES IT WAS NOT PROHIBITED. EVEN SAGE APASTHAMBA ALSO MENTIONED IN HIS SUTRAS - THERE ARE CERTAIN MEATS RECOMMENDED FOR CERTAIN OCCASSIONS. FOR THOSE DAYS, THEY WERE IN PRACTICE AND ACCEPTED BY THE SOCIETY.

BUT NOT NOW!!!!.

* WHEN OUR ACHARYAS OBSERVED SOME PROBLEMS WITH CERTAIN PRACTICES, THEY PROHIBITED SOME A:CHA:RAS, EVEN THOUGH THOSE A:CHA:RAS WERE RECOMMENDED BY SA:STHRAS.
* WHATEVER THE SA:STRAS CONDEMNED, WERE ALSO GIVEN UP IN ALL AGES.
* EVEN AMONG THE RECOMMENDED PRACTICES ALSO CERTAIN THINGS WERE NOT TAKEN UP FOR USAGE, WHICH MAY SHOW NEGITIVE IMPACT ON THESE WEAK MINDS & HEARTS OF KALIYUGA. ACHARYAS MUST BE KNOWING ABOUT THEM.
* EATING MEAT, DRINKING MADHUVU, PERFORMING YAGAS WITH ANIMAL SACRIFICE WERE A FEW OF SUCH KIND.
* WE BETTER BE BY OURSELVES, AND NEED NOT PLAY RAMA. TRY TO LEARN GOOD THINGS FROM THEM
* AS A COMMON MAN, ONE MAY EAT ANYTHING THAT ONE'S RELATIVES AND PARENTS HAVE TAUGHT THEM.
* BUT, WHEN ONE CHOOSES TO BE A SIMPLE PRACTITIONER OF SOME SCHOOL OF THOUGHT, THEN, THAT PERSON SHOULD STRICTLY FOLLOW THE ACHARYA OF THAT PARTICULAR SCHOOL.
* NO QUESTIONS ARE ASKED, AS LONG AS THAT ACHARYA RECOMMENDS EVEN UNPROHIBITED ACTIVITES.
* ONE NEED NOT QUESTION THAT ACHARYA, TO GET THE SANCTION OF ONE'S OWN INTENTIONS.
* FOR EXAMPLE: IF YOU WANT TO EAT MEAT, SIMPLY GO AND EAT AS MUCH AS YOU CAN AND AS FREQUENTLY AS POSSIBLE. BUT, KNOWINGLY, DO NOT ARGUE WITH ACHARYA & ALSO DO NOT TRY TO JUSTIFY SAYING THAT EATING MEAT IS SA:STRIC BY SHOWING THE EXAMPLES OF RAMA, KRISHNA OR SOMEONE.
* AND ALSO, DO NOT FORCE ACHARYA TO ACCEPT WHATEVER YOU DID, AS RIGHT.
* THAT MAY BE MENTIONED IN SA:STRAS AND MANY PEOPLE MIGHT HAVE DONE IT, SO ON & SO FORTH. STILL, IF THAT ACHARYA DOES NOT WANT IT AND DID NOT RECOMMEND IN HIS SAMPRADAYA, DUTY OF A FOLLOWER IS TO AVOID IT SIMPLY, WITHOUT ANY ARGUMENT.
* OTHERWISE, BETTER NOT TO POSE AS A FOLLOWER AND CHEAT.
* EVERYBODY HAS ONE'S OWN WAY OF PRACTISING THINGS. FOLLOWERS SHOULD UNDERSTAND THAT. ONE NEED NOT COMPARE & COMMENT THAT PRACTICE OF ONE ACHARYA WITH THE PRACTICE OF ANOTHER ACHARYA OF ANOTHER SAMPRADAYAM OR EVEN OF THE SAME SAMPRADAYAM TOO. IT IS ALWAYS BAD.

To put in short, one need not exhibit so-called enlightenment and extensive knowledge, in posing clever questions thus wasting the time and energy of many. There is a lot of useful work to be done.

==Chinnajeeyar="
 
Comments:
From: Srinivasaramanujan TCA

Adiyen's humble obeisance at the lotus feet of His Holiness Sri Sri Sri Chinna Jeeyar Swamivaru.

The clarifications given in "Message: 5 Subject: RE: Q - Did Rama eat meat?" reveal the arjava[dispassionate intellectual honesty] of Swamivaru. The candid acknowledgment of Sri Rama's meat eating habit shows his scrupulous regard for truth. His Holiness has rightly considered the following verses depicting the Lord's condition after separation from Sri Sita:

Na ma'msam Ra'ghavo bhungt'e na c'a'pi madhu sevat'e/
Vanyam su vihit'am nit'yam bhakt'am as'na't'i panc'amam/
Naiva d'ams'a'n na mas'aka'n na ki'ta'n na sari'srupa'n/
Ra'ghavopanayet' ga't'ra't' t'vadgat'ena'nt'ara't'mana'/
Nit'yam d'hya'na paro Ra'mo nit'yam s'oka para'yan'h/
Na'nyac'c'int'ayat'e kinc'it' sa t'u ka'mavas'amgat'ah
[Sundara Kanda-Sarga 36]

Adiyen Madhurakavidasan,
TCASrinivasaramanujan
 
Posting for HH Chinna Jeeyar Swamiji

Priya Sriman Srinivasa Ramanujanji!
Jai Srimannarayana!

You have mentioned only from Sundara Kandam. See Ayodhya Kandam. When Rama left for forest, after going away from Guha, Rama ate meat. In chitrakutam He ate meat. In fact, they were drying the meat when Kakasura came there. While they were in forest they ate. After Sita was taken away by Ravana, while Rama killed Kumbhakarna, he in another form directs Rama to go to Sugri:va, after meeting with Sabari. Then that demon says Rama the route to go to Rushyamuka. And says what type of birds and fish to eat on the way. There are many places where it is mentioned that Rama ate meat.

But, here the point is should we also eat if He eats? This reminds a story from the life of Sankaracharya.

His disciples were trying to imitate in all respects. Most of the times, such disciples try to follow the gurus to avoid some practices which are, they think, difficult to follow. Acharya Sankara observed that and did not want to warn them. But he wanted to show something to them. While going for Bhiksha, on the way, where there was gold-smith shop and gold was melted in a mould, Acharya took the mould and dropped into his mouth. The disciples who wanted to imitate everything, also wanted to drink it after the Guru. But he could not even touch the mould and felt ashamed for his ignorance.

There will be many incidents in Rama's life also. We need to take a few, which are needed to set our lives. Learn more about them and follow. Leave rest of the things. Why they did and how they did in those days are not necessary for us.

There will be many thorns on the stack of the rose. You need a rose. Take it and be happy. Why thorns to that? Is not our concern. It is the concern of God. There will be hundreds of things around the world. You take whatever you deserve and need. Questioning about other things is not your concern. You better mind your own business, this has to be understood by the people who are posing unnecessary questions.

=Chinnajeeyar=
 
below link can be helpful to answer this doubt...

http://www.ariseindiaforum.org/vegetarianism.php?type=1
 
Please I request you to go through the holy quran and you will definitely get the answers its available in regional languages with translation will solve the purpose of your life
 
Post a Comment



<< Home
The Lord, Srimannarayana is the supreme godhead for our Hindu Sanatana Dharma. His abode is 'Vaikuntam', also known as 'Paramapadam'. The Lord takes birth on this earth to upkeep Dharma and these incarnations of God is what we, 'Mandhamatis' seek refuge in. My acharya, HH Sri Chinna Jeeyar Swamiji, very rightly preaches 'Serve all beings as Service to God', 'Respect All and Worship your own'. Here, I share my experiences in my spiritual walk of life - Karthik Nagaraj

HH Swamiji
ARCHIVES
04/01/2005 - 05/01/2005 / 05/01/2005 - 06/01/2005 / 06/01/2005 - 07/01/2005 / 07/01/2005 - 08/01/2005 / 10/01/2005 - 11/01/2005 / 11/01/2005 - 12/01/2005 / 12/01/2005 - 01/01/2006 / 01/01/2006 - 02/01/2006 / 03/01/2006 - 04/01/2006 / 04/01/2006 - 05/01/2006 / 05/01/2006 - 06/01/2006 / 09/01/2006 - 10/01/2006 / 11/01/2006 - 12/01/2006 /


Powered by Blogger